Tuesday, October 23, 2018

 reply to comment of Strzeleckis re: youtube video How did Apollo deal with the Van Allen radiation belts ?

yes NASA spent a lot of money on a space shuttle which only puts up 1/6 as much payload into orbit at a costs of 3 times as much as the Apollo Saturn V
That is factually incorrect - it cost half as much as Saturn V launch, and could also put half as much payload into orbit.
-- Source citations are in order.  Here are mine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3uhZJbtPm4E&t=4h13m57s


all of the above achievements were indeed even greater than Apollo for the simple fact that every single Apollo landing was staged in a studio here on earth.
No matter how many times you repeat that falsehood, it won't become true.
-- And no matter how many times you repeat your false statement that they did safely land on the moon, it won't become true.  Its just more fraud. There is only one truth.

these days NASA is required to pursue commercial options for launching spaceflight missions.
-- it's funny how Jan qualifies his statement with "these days", as if NASAs fat friends somehow didn't see a lot of pork from NASA in the past.

NASA was originally comprised entirely of paperclip Nazi and german assets from WWII
Not really, no. There was this little dainty agency called NACA first - and in fact, NASA initially didn't want Von Braun's help, which is why USSR has managed to beat them with Sputnik.  
-- NACA = National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, formed in 1915?  They no doubt held many committee meetings for sending a biplane to the moon.
But, granted NASA was not completely comprised of Nazi, just had a very large complement of them.

And today NASA is comprised entirely of plums positions
I don't suppose you have any evidence to prove this peculiar claim of yours?
-- any fool can see it.  

And, its painfully evident from this interview that Musk only recently found out that the entire Apollo program was a sham, and is frustrated by it.
 Creative reinterpretation of someone's words does not constitute evidence in any way, shape or form.  
-- On the contrary, the evidence is circumstantial.  And, I encourage Jan to regale us with an alternative interpretation of what Musk might have been thinking when he said those words in that interview, and to what Musk could possibly have been referring.  And, clichés like, 'in any way, shape or form' are just superfluous and stuffy and typical of sophistry.  Just fyi

He likely did not realise how bad the radiation was in deep space.
Excuse me? You do realize that EGRET's Moon photo was taken between 1991 and 1994, right? This data is over twenty four years old! In what peculiar alternate reality publicly releasing this supposedly damaging data that supposedly proves that the gamma radiation is much more serious than NASA ever claimed counts as "stiffling innovation" and "claiming that there isn't a problem"?  This data was available for everybody. An entire world.
-- The gamma radiation is dangerous but, moreover, is an indicator of the presence of the real danger, the high velocity cosmic ray particles coming from all directions, traveling close to the speed of light.
   Yes, data is sometimes made available to the public and played down, e.g.  Aflatoxin in peanut butter, mercury in silver fillings, methyl-mercury in all fish (but sardines are relatively safe) caused by coal burning, fructose being a chronic toxin, MSG causing obesity, CT scan contrast dyes causing permanent kidney damage, all pharmaceutical products causing kidney damage for that matter, decrease in world oxygen levels, South American rain forest depletion numbers.
    Van Allen himself originally said the Van Allen belts were deadly, but later changed his tune, no doubt under pressure from pork addicts.  As it turned out, he was right the first time.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=szh5cuzfiN4
    It was later made known that the Van Allen belts were more dangerous than was realised when the space shuttle in 1998 was sent 350 miles up, which reportedly caused the astronauts to see stars when their eyes were closed, from radiation penetrating the space capsule, then their space suits, and then their skulls, to react directly with the retnas of their eyes, thereby confirming Dr. Van Allen's initial report.  The Apollo astronauts evidently had no idea this was the case.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3uhZJbtPm4E&t=13m41s
    No, theres nothing to see here.  And, the average person doesn't even realise that the moon is a gamma-ray source.

If some scientists in, say, Russia on China wanted to "reveal the truth", there wouldn't be a damn thing that NASA could've done about it.
-- o rly?  Someone should go tell that to Gus Grissom, Ed White, Roger Chaffee, James Erwin or Thomas Baron or anyone else mentioned in this article https://aplanetruth.info/2015/03/31/24-why-did-so-many-apollo-astronots-die-mysterious-deaths-in-just-three-years-time/.   As far as Russia goes, there is evidence that shows them faking some of their stuff, like this clip of Yuri Gagarin in a studio environment which simulates being in the Vostok capsule, and then no doubt swapped out of the capsule before launch, while the gantry movement was creating a distraction: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3uhZJbtPm4E&t=3h49m12s  

telling the world that radiation in space is relatively safe
It isn't, but radiation is safely survivable when the exposure time is short.
-- By space I meant outer space and not low earth orbit.  And by not relatively safe, I mean acute radiation sickness, not some supposed cardiovascular risk elevation later in life, which is plain bogus.  Anyone in outer space would be irradiated.

There is a saying where I come from, 'if its not broke dont fix it'.
How about "necessity breeds invention"? Or "we've built a new piece of hardware - it would be a good idea to test it to see how it works."
-- Or, "liar liar pants on fire", "birds of a feather flock together"

after 50 years NASA should be able to put a man on the moon, given todays age of technology, which is actually a reasonable expectation that even paid NASA trolls like Jan should be able to honestly, logically and reasonably address
If they had the money, they would.  Don't blame NASA - blame politicians. NASA had Apollo program planned up to Apollo 20, followed by Apollo Applications Program, to perform missions beyond Moon using Apollo hardware. Is that honest, logical and reasonly enough for you?
-- It's not reasonable.  Thats the whole point of this argument thread.  If that was a reasonable argument then people wouldn't by asking why NASA still hasnt put a man on the moon for 50 years, after doing it so easily under "I'm not a crook" Nixon.  

Requiring knowledge of precisely how high the radiative flux density may be before actually stating that it poses an imminent danger to those exposed to it is just a lot superfluous hand waving
Stating that "it poses and imminent danger" is quantifying it: "the radiative flux density is high enough to pose an imminent danger to those exposed." So all I'm saying is, "prove it".
-- Establishing that "it poses and imminent danger" can be deduced either quantitatively or qualitatively or both, just like stating that being inside a house when its on fire poses an imminent danger.  One doesn't need to hold out a thermometer to the flame to ascertain precise quantitative proof to determine whether or or not one will get burned if touching it.
    Proof is in the gamma ray images of the moon and the realisation that there are billions upon billions of sources of cosmic rays, radiating in every direction from hundreds of billions of galaxies, billions of light years away, unhindered and unimpeded.   All one needs to do is count how many distant galaxies are pictured in this linked article, which pertains to how Hubble was pointed at a point of empty blackness in space about 1/30 the size of a full moon for 100 hours, to get even a gross appreciation of how many cosmic ray sources there are.  The galaxies pictured, and not pictured, are spewing forth unimpeded debris from supernova and other cosmic ray sources.  https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/phenomena/2015/04/24/when-hubble-stared-at-nothing-for-100-hours/
   For example, once every 50 years, more or less, a massive star explodes into a supernova somewhere in the Milky Way galaxy.  In the 3000 galaxies pictured, there are about 3000 such supernovae every 50 years, which is 60 per year.   The total number of large galaxies within 2 billion light years of us is roughly 25 million with at least ten times as many dwarf galaxies.  Of these mere 250 million galaxies that lie within 2 billion light years of us, there are 250 million supernova every 50 years, which is about 8 supernovae every second, that we are feeling, all from random directions.
    And, unlike gamma-rays, whose energy is depleted by the expansion of the universe stretching out their wavelength, the relative velocity of cosmic ray particles that are traveling from these vastly distant galaxies does not decrease for the simple fact that the earth is not truly accelerating away from them, but rather remains relatively close to stationary; there is merely an ever increasing expansion of space that mysteriously appears between the particles origin and the earth which does not effect the momentum of these cosmic ray particles.
    The Van Allen belt tends to redirect cosmic particle radiation around the earth, caused by the earths magnetic field; so, given that our atmosphere also provides additional shielding, its reasonable to presume that the background cosmic radiation on earth is much lower than what you would experience in deep space, so people remain for the most part unaware.  If it wasnt for our atmosphere and magnetic field, the earth would be glowing with gamma rays just like the moon is at this very moment.

    But, NASA fully well knows the quantitative radiation readings and is covering them up for the sake of covering their own arses, as well as securing tax dollar appropriated pork barrels for their friends.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2NeNr3TrBFg&t=32m02s

No comments:

Post a Comment