Friday, October 26, 2018

Reply to comment of Strzelecki re: youtube video How did Apollo deal with the Van Allen radiation belts ?


Source citations are in order. Here are mine:
Your source is... Bill Wood impersonator? 
-- Far be it for anyone to even presume that two different people could possibly possess the same first and last names, if the film was indeed trying to impersonate the Bill Wood that Strzelecki was referring to then they wouldn't have referred to him as Bill Wood, BSc.  BSc clearly means that he holds a bachelors of science degree.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3uhZJbtPm4E&t=3h57m43s .  The other Bill Wood worked his way up from technician and doesn't even hold a degree, but they must be the same anyway, amirite?  Oh, and look at this. Percy does indeed interview the Bill Wood, to which Strzelecki is referring, in this clip as Billy talks about the "live" Apollo coverage that wasn't really live at all but played from numerous video recorders:
 https://www.youtube.com/watch?src_vid=c0rKyHdVizI&v=3uhZJbtPm4E&t=2h48m40s
While flailing with baseless accusations, and driveling snot, Strzelecki is once again conveniently incorrect, likely for the purpose of furthering some sort of sinister defamation agenda.  In fact, I would wager that most people at this point would conclude that Strzelecki has already shown himself to be dishonest.

FYI, here's how real Bill Wood looks like: https://www.hq.nasa.gov/alsj/billwood.html 
-- Thats correct.  Strzelecki has actually provided us with a correct statement!  But, it still has nothing to do with the price of tea in China, as this is a totally different person altogether.


Don't you get it? Those people, Bill Kaysing, Bart Sibrel, Mary Bennet, David Percy - they're lying to you.
-- Clearly Strzelecki does not get it.  Someone, Strzelecki for example, that emotionally flails their arms, fervently claiming that someone else is bearing false witness, really needs to provide more than just the words, 'they are lying', to back up their claim, well, someone that is not being totally dishonest, or a paid NASA troll anyway.

There's no "Bill Wood BSc" 
-- I could just as easily say the same thing about "Jan Strzelecki no-degree millennial",  based on the very presumptuous lack of evidence presented.

but they wanted people to think that this was Bill Wood who worked as an Apollo comm supervisor, to lend credence to their false claims.
-- And, Strzelcki further summarizes this baseless narrative as if it were fact.  In most cultures people are taught at a young age to at least feel some form of shame or remorse for bearing false testimony.  What has happened to this world that we live in, with this rogue millennial generation.  Ethics no longer exist when its inconvenient.  And, hedonism and selfish gain acquired through fraud is the acceptable unquestioned status-quo.

And no matter how many times you repeat your false statement that they did safely land men on the moon doesn't make it so. 
Yeah, yeah, now you're just saying "no" for the sake of saying "no" :)  
-- Obviously, I'm saying "no" in this instance because Strzelecki is once again incorrect

it's funny how Strzelecki qualifies his statement with "these days", as if NASAs fat friends somehow didn't see a lot of pork from NASA in the past.
That is completely and utterly beside the point.
-- Pork is the point.

So I take it you concede that Elon Musk was able to develop the Falcon thanks to NASA?  
-- Elon Musk was able to develop the Falcon in spite of NASA.


National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, formed in 1915? They no doubt held many committee meetings for sending a biplane to the moon.
Biplane, no, rocket, yes, starting in 1957. granted NASA was not completely comprised of Nazi, just had a very large complement of them 127 people out of 7,500 former NACA employes is "very large"? :)
-- 127 is in this case a large complement of Nazi taking tax payer funded jobs away from non-Nazi Americans.  how admirable.

NASA is comprised entirely of plums and any fool can see it. 
Oh, so you don't have any evidence. Thought so. 
-- As Strzelecki so often finds himself saying when he is too lazy to dig through and actually name anything specific, there is a "consilience" of evidence.

On the contrary, the evidence is circumstantial.
"Here's what I think Musk meant" is not evidence, even circumstantial, in any way, shape or form.
-- Again, to the contrary, the evidence is circumstantial.

And, I encourage Strzelecki to regale us with an alternative interpretation of what Musk might have been thinking
I don't know what he was thinking, and neither do you. That's the point. "Here's what I think - prove me wrong" is not an argument in any way, shape or form - it's the exact opposite of an argument. 
-- Circumstantial evidence is evidence that relies on an inference to connect it to a conclusion of fact.  The simple fact is that there is no other conceivable thing that Elon Musk could have possibly been referring to in that interview (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CQbKctnnA-Y&t=1m12s) besides the total laughable fact that NASA cannot safely send humans beyond low earth orbit, and faked every single Apollo moon landing, and pulled the wool over the eyes of the entire world for almost 50 years.  And, since Strzelecki believes somehow that the words in the linked video of Elon Musk must be referring to something else entirely different, I again challenge Strzelecki to entertain us with whatever that something else might be.  Oh, he can't?  Thought so.

The gamma radiation is dangerous but, moreover, is an indicator of the presence of the real danger, the high velocity cosmic ray particles
The high velocity cosmic ray particles, unlike gamma radiation, can be blocked by polyethylene, which can also double as an insulator. This was also known for a long while.  
-- And, I am currently waiting for Strzelecki to go put on his polyethylene suit and stick his head in a Large Hadron Collider while its accelerating a beam full of protons traveling at velocities which although may approach light speed still aren't as fast as cosmic rays are able to travel, to actually see how effective his polyethylene suit proves be.  Where LHC can accelerate protons to a maximum of 99.99999991% the speed of light, cosmic rays have been known to travel at 99.999999999999999999999995% the speed of light. Where the density of lead is 11.34 g/cm3, the average bone mineral density is around 3.88 g/cm2, and that's where these cosmic rays will cause secondary radiation, if this so called light polyethylene shielding is employed.
 
Yes, data is sometimes made available to the public and played down
In exactly what way NASA's data was "played down"? You don't know, do you?
-- By saying that the astronauts that allegedly walked on the moon may only have suffer elevated cardiovascular risks later in life is in fact "playing it down", or more specifically, deemphasizing the truth with a blatantly incorrect statement. 

You just believe that space radiation is extremely dangerous, and therefore NASA had to play the danger down? That's not much of an argument.  
-- Cosmic rays are extremely dangerous and NASA does not wish for anyone to know just how dangerous because they would prefer not to be indicted for defrauding tax payers out of half a trillion dollars.   So, there is definite cui-bono to the argument.

Van Allen himself originally said the Van Allen belts were deadly
And they are, with long exposure and no shielding.  
According to Van Allens initial report, 1 inch of lead will be required to stop 90% of the radiation and 6 inches of lead to stop 99% of the radiation.  How much lead did Apollo have again? 
 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=szh5cuzfiN4&t=19m45s
Oh they ran through it quickly?  Like when one runs through the rain more quickly thinking that they will get less wet?  Radiation exposure is accumulative and cannot be dried off later, and keeping in mind that going to the moon could not be achieved in a straight line; the craft would have to circle the earth, traveling from lower orbitals to higher ones.

but Van Allen later changed his tune, no doubt under pressure from pork addicts. As it turned out, he was right the first time.
"The first time"? In what way refining your findings thanks to better measurements means that the original findings are correct?
-- In the same way that installing digital voting machine without paper trails is the newest thing and must therefore provide more accurate results.

And, speaking of "pork addicts", there is immense worldwide economic incentive to having the best available data on the VABs
-- And, its in the very best interests of corrupt politicians to replace old voting machines with the newest ones that don't have paper trails, because they are obviously better at concealing corruption and fraud.

y'know, satellites, probes, and other devices intended to operate in and beyond the VABs. If NASA had under-reported the actual radiation present, as you claim, all the stuff engineered to those standards would all have failed prematurely due to radiation damage.
-- One can irradiate their toaster a million times without it failing to cook toast and without it getting cancer or vomiting in its space suit.  Similarly, its easier to shield sensitive digital equipment than it is to shield human beings.  They obviously aren't made of the same "stuff".

It was later made known that the Van Allen belts were more dangerous than was realised when the space shuttle in 1998 was sent 350 miles up, which reportedly caused the astronauts to see stars when their eyes were closed
This cosmic ray visual phenomena (google it) is well known and has been observed as early as Apollo 11 mission. In what way does it make VABs "more dangerous"?
-- The CNN report, as well as the latest astronaut testimonies caught on camera, certainly support the premise that these experiences were never observed prior.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3uhZJbtPm4E&t=13m41s
In 1998 CNN reported: “The radiation belts surrounding Earth may be more dangerous for astronauts than previously believed. The phenomenon known as the ‘Van Allen Belts’ can spawn [newly discovered] ‘Killer Electrons’ [...]  These electrons that are being studied [...] could also effect the astronauts by creating large doses of radiation ..."


What does it even have to do with VABs? Why are you even talking about them? I thought your concern was with gamma and particle radiation from deep space, beyond VABs?
-- The Van Allen belts are in space duh.  And there is no way to avoid them completely on the way to the moon.  But, it is clearly evident that Strzelecki wishes to avoid them.

And, the average person doesn't even realise that the moon is a gamma-ray source.
True, but completely and utterly irrelevant.
-- Once again Strzelecki is Incorrect.  Its obviously relevant when considering sending astronauts to the moon who are then intent upon going outside and jumping up and down for days and days with mere polyethylene and aluminum foil for shielding.

Someone should go tell that to Gus Grissom, Ed White, Roger Chaffee, James Erwin or Thomas Baron or anyone else mentioned in this article https://aplanetruth.info/2015/03/31/24-why-did-so-many-apollo-astronots-die-mysterious-deaths-in-just-three-years-time/.
What part of "If some scientists in, say, Russia or China wanted to "reveal the truth", there wouldn't be a damn thing that NASA could've done about it"
you didn't understand? Why are you telling me about dead American astronauts? Moving goalposts much? 
-- This is true; these aforementioned people were not in Russia or China, but were murdered nonetheless.  And, it seems quite apparent that Strzeleckis wishes to avoid discussing this as an example of what happens to whistle blowers.  No, no only the ones in Russia or in China matter, he says.
   Soviet cosmonaut Leonov explicitly stated that the Soviet side understood immediately that some of the photo/video footage allegedly coming from the Moon was filmed in a studio on Earth. They reported their opinion to the country political leadership. Yet there was nothing in news about it.
   There was (and still is) some collusion between Russia and the US on a very high level.  The Moscow theater gassing in 2002 is likely an example of this, where after being detained, the surviving detained terrorists somehow simply vanish months later without a trace.  And, the terrorists would only negotiate through the Red Cross, which has been associated with CIA.
   Furthermore, there might be reason to believe Sergei Korolevs death may have been an assassination.  Srsly, the guy checks into hospital for a routine appendix and checks out as a corpse.  The only other guy that comes to mind when I think about Sergei is Andy Warhol, who was perhaps killed for the purpose of increasing the value of his art, like Otis Redding, Curt Cobain, Tupac and Selena Quintanilla-Perez, just to name a few, but thats another story.

As far as Russia goes, there is evidence that shows them faking some of their stuff, like this clip of Yuri Gagarin
As already established, Mary Bennett and David Percy are not credible sources.
-- As we have already established, Strzelecki has failed to establish that Mary Bennett and David Percy are not credible sources.

 For all we know, they've probably spliced the footage themselves to produce this "anomaly". 
-- More baseless conjecture.

And even if they didn't, what exactly does it prove?
 Gagarin was first man in space. USA admitted it,
-- Indeed, the USA admitted many untruths.


 and even if they knew at the time that the Russians cheated a bit wouldn't change this fact. And Russians confirmed that USA landed on the Moon, having much more to lose than the early stage of the race.
-- No one had anything to lose, besides funding.  It was all merely an orchestrated productive game, and one more entertaining than global thermonuclear war.  Both sides took photos in studios and cheated a lot.

Today, either Russia or China (your total avoidance of China in your argument is duly noted, btw) has even better incentive to blow the whistle, and yet, they do not. How peculiar... 
-- and only Nixon can go to China.
China is not only the largest industrial base in the world but is also the largest consumer base in the world and the US will cow tow as much as it is able.  The current US China trade wars is mere political posturing to make Trump look good as he vies for time, since he is playing his cultural populism card, playing up to the reactionaries and racists, which is pretty much every-buddy.  But, rest assured, after election day he will execute a jaw dropping perfectly performed boot-legger 180 maneuver and cave in to all of Chinas demands.  And, China knows this.  Why hasn't China blown the whistle?  Perhaps they are withholding it as a bargaining chip, and are simply pretending to be up at arms about the trumps proposed tariffs that they know will never happen.  Perhaps those that were in a position to do so were already bought off, which, given the current state of corruption there, is completely plausible.  Perhaps they destroyed their technology.  ( ikr :)

Or, "liar liar pants on fire", "birds of a feather flock together" You're just saying "no" for the sake of saying "no", again :) I mean, really, what is so strange about the idea of testing new equipment in its intended working conditions?
-- What is really so strange about repeating a process that has allegedly worked in the past, like safely landing men on the moon?
And Strzelecki was clearly suppose to follow the same pattern of response by answering in terms of ancient sayings wisdom, but sadly fails in this regard.

It's not reasonable. Thats the whole point of this argument thread.
It's the truth. Truth doesn't have to be "reasonable". The Congress has reduced NASA's funding. That's a fact. Up to early 2000's, NASA was directed to focus its effort on Space Shuttle. That's also a fact. You might not like it, and I don't like it either, too, but not liking it or (quite correctly) declaring it to be unreasonable doesn't change the reality.
-- Its like saying they broke the sound barrier in 1947 but 50 years later no one can do it.  Budget cuts my ass.  They may as well have said that their dog, not only had eaten all their homework, but also ate all the hardware and people to which their homework was referring.  A logical argument is always based on reason.  And, an unreasonable explanation is generally and indicator of deception lies and FRAUD.
    Occam's razor states that the simplest solution is correct, in so many words.  The simplest solution in this case just happens to be the truth; NASA is lying its ass off in hopes of not getting caught and thrown in jail.  So much for suspension of disbelief.  Nixon didnt even go to the first 3 Apollo launches, no doubt for fear of getting dirty if it was exposed, well dirtier than he already was, which is saying quite a bit.
    Let us not even consider the possibility of merely decreasing NASAs funding.  NASA's should be made to repay the tax payers for their fraud.  It reminds me of that time in 2014 when a single Los Alamos official cost the nation 2 billion dollars, not including collateral, by experimenting with a cheaper waste filler, and then venting it after it exploded a waste container.  Was he fired?  No, the contractors payment was reduced a mere 57 million for that year, and then it was business as usual.  The corruption stinks high.

Establishing that "it poses and imminent danger" can be deduced either quantitatively or qualitatively or both
Hey, Sherlock, news flash: scientists don't "deduce" values - they measure them.
-- Once again, Strzelecki's is playing word games.  Scientists measure values and deduce outcomes based on those values.  But, the values aren't necessarily numerical in composition.  And, Strzelecki clearly needs a lesson in semantics.  Why do I suddenly feel like a secondary school teacher?


just like stating that being inside a house when its on fire poses an imminent danger.
Yet again, that depends on your exposure time. If you spend 5 seconds inside, you'll most likely be fine afterwards. If you spend 5 minutes?.. Probably not so much.  And that is the point. Exposure time matters, no matter how much you squirm and flail, and wave your arms around.  
-- And, likewise, Strzeleckis can flail his arms all he wants shouting about exposure time while his house is burning down around him, and would be in imminent danger while doing so.  The point is that NASA is grossly understating the radiation on the moon, as well as in the Van Allen belts.   Using Strzeleckis argument, one can run around for 3 days on the moon and still not be exposed to enough constant gamma and cosmic radiation to cause radiation sickness (not to mention fogging of the Hasselblad photographic film), which simply isn't the case, given that the moon is always glowing brightly in gamma rays from cosmic ray particles striking it at velocities approaching the speed of light, as well as slower moving particles colliding with it to produce x-rays.

But, NASA fully well knows the quantitative radiation readings but is covering them up
No, they don't. Time and again, article after article, video after video, they keep emphasizing how hazardous radiation is, and they keep releasing quantitative readings. It's almost as if they weren't covering anything up!
-- Yes, they do.  Its merely an old Nixon trick called "limited hangout".  Strzelecki needs to go look it up.  And if it wasnt for the earths magnetic field and atmosphere, the earth would be constantly glowing in gamma rays just as the moon is at this very moment.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Moon_egret.jpg   https://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap160429.html

as well as securing tax dollar appropriated pork barrels for their friends.
Aaand you've linked to Bart Sibrel again. Is there anyone among your sources who isn't a fraud, or a liar, or creatively misrepresented?
-- One who goes around calling others liars without proof could be sued for slander.  One who puts it in writing could be sued for libel.  So far I've seen no proof, nor even reasonable evidence, coming out of Strzelecki, just a lot of flailing irresponsible incorrect statements.


No comments:

Post a Comment